Vibration evaluation

Judges ISO 10816-3 zones A to D from the RMS vibration velocity. Relative judgment by the ratio to the normal value, and how to choose measurement points.

Measure your normal values
ahead of time, and you can
spot any change!

Chips, the Kezuriba mascot

÷Vibration assessment

Zone assessment (guide from ISO 10816-3)

Relative assessment (ratio to normal value)

ISO 10816-3 is an evaluation for rotating machinery such as pumps, fans, and electric motors, and is not a criterion for machine tool spindles themselves. The boundary values are read from an explanatory figure by the vibration meter maker IMV.

Use the RMS vibration velocity (mm/s rms) to evaluate machine vibration

Vibration is expressed as displacement (µm, mm), velocity (mm/s), or acceleration (m/s²). Velocity is used to judge the severity of machine vibration; displacement is used when the amplitude itself matters, such as for machining accuracy or the risk of contact; acceleration is used when you want to look at high frequencies. Because ISO's evaluation of machine vibration uses RMS velocity, expressing it as RMS has become normal in Japan too.[1][2]

RMS value, peak value, and crest factor

For a sine wave: peak value = RMS value × √2  /  crest factor CF = peak value ÷ RMS value

The RMS value is the square root of the mean of the squared instantaneous values over a fixed time, and corresponds to the energy contained in the waveform. The crest factor is a clue when comparing bearing deterioration relatively (IMV).[2][1]

Machine groups in ISO 10816-3:2009

GroupRange
Group 1 (large machines)Output 300 kW–50 MW, shaft height 315 mm or more
Group 2 (medium machines)Output 15 kW–300 kW, shaft height 160–315 mm

These are further divided by whether the foundation (installation) is "rigid" or "flexible". This evaluation is for rotating machinery such as pumps, fans, and electric motors, not for machine tool spindles themselves.[3](1 source, for reference)

Zone boundaries in ISO 10816-3:2009 (RMS vibration velocity, mm/s)

GroupA/B boundaryB/C boundaryC/D boundary
Group 2, rigid1.42.84.5
Group 2, flexible2.34.57.1
Group 1, rigid2.34.57.1
Group 1, flexible3.57.111

Boundary values read from IMV's figure ("Examples of good/poor judgment by machine group"). The zones are A: good, B: acceptable, C: warning, D: danger (IMV's labels). The standard itself is paid, and conditions such as the zone definition text and the measurement frequency range were not checked.[3](1 source, for reference)

Three methods of simple diagnosis

MethodDescriptionNotes
Absolute assessmentDivide by machine type and size, and treat exceeding a set value as abnormal (e.g., ISO evaluation criteria)Easy to judge, but the proper value differs by machine type, part, and maker
Relative assessmentCompare with the machine's own normal-condition value. Example: caution at 2 times normal, danger at 5 timesIt is preferable to set the reference value from 10 or more measurements
Mutual (comparative) assessmentCompare the same measurement point across several identical machines in a row. If it is 2 times or more that of equivalent equipment, an abnormality is possibleLimited to cases where such machines are available

[3](1 source, for reference)

Rotation speed and vibration frequency

f (Hz) = n (min⁻¹) ÷ 60

Example: for a fan bearing running at 1,860 min⁻¹, the rotation frequency is 31 Hz. In an FFT, a large component at the rotation frequency with few harmonics suggests imbalance, and a prominent 2nd order (twice the frequency) suggests misalignment (Rion's example).[1](1 source, for reference)

When looking for bearing abnormalities

To detect bearing and abnormal sounds, envelope processing (IMV's H function) that applies a 2–15 kHz filter to the acceleration waveform is effective. Estimating the cause from the components corresponding to the rotation frequency is precision diagnosis (FFT analysis).[3][2](1 source, for reference)

How to choose measurement points

Choose a point that meets these 5 conditions: easy to reach, little affected by anything other than the abnormality, sensitive to changes in the abnormality, little signal attenuation, and measurable the same way every time. Measuring on the bearing housing is the basic rule.[2](1 source, for reference)

Vibration of a machine tool spindle

Haas's preventive maintenance measures spindle vibration, compares it with the reference, and uses the records as the baseline for future comparison (progress of wear). Whether ISO 10816 zone values can be applied to a machine tool spindle could not be confirmed in public documents.[4](1 source, for reference)

📚Sources

Items without a mark are those on which two or more materials from different publishers agree. For product values, each manufacturer's documentation takes precedence. The text is summarized in Kezuriba's own words.

  1. Rion, "Mechanical Vibration Measurement (Technical Note)"
  2. IMV, "Vibration Measurement Library, Chapter 4: Vibration Technical Guide"
  3. IMV, "Vibration Measurement Library, Chapter 5: How to Measure Vibration (simple diagnosis judgment methods and figure from ISO 10816-3:2009)"
  4. Haas Automation, "Preventive Maintenance Program (Haas Factory Outlet document)"